Hi TacoBelle , "rid the rooms" sounds very negative and was not suggested by anyone. As stated, to me, it's about choice. Another user phrased it as "offer" people something. If people have a choice of #sexchat or #otherchat, then some will choose #otherchat if it has a large enough audience and it's a well chosen topic of #otherchat which will lead to less traffic in #sexchat. That is the whole point as it was presented to us. Not to kick someone out but at least, by motivation, to make some want to chat more in #otherchat and less #sexchat. To encourage (not forbid or rid) more traffic to move to other rooms. My point is that I see these suggestions not made in a judgemental atmosphere (mine certainly aren't) but in the spirit of what the thread calls for. It's fair enough if some channel ideas are considered and rejected. And I think your reasons as stated make total sense. As I said I do understand if this particular room idea won't happen for certain reasons. The idea was originally suggested as different-language channel. However, the suggestion (in its purest form) could still be made as a cultural suggestion with the language of the channel still being English. The same rules as in all the other channels could still apply. Generally speaking I do agree with you that national/cultural channels en masse would be a bad idea but this particular one makes more sense as it's a very large portion of the users on the site. But as mentioned I do get if it's considered and found non-desirable for other reasons. I certainly neither said, nor think that about you. You completely misunderstood my point. Among other things my point was that it's jumping to conclusions to assume that suggestions in this thread are made out of intolerance by others (it certainly wasn't by me, I do talk to Indians as well as all other nationalities/cultures). All my posts in this thread have been serious and on topic, some even with original ideas (the thread does also call for posts to support ideas of others). On that topic, you did previously in the thread suggest that people not waste time on suggestions that have been vetoed. Would it be possible to get an official list of ideas that were considered but rejected categorically? The reasons for rejection wouldn't have to be given if that would be a concern, it would just be nice to know so those ideas don't get suggested again as you pointed out. I am still hoping for some of the ideas in this thread to go through (your trivia idea for instance would be fun if it could be made to work) and it would be interesting to know if they have been rejected or are still in consideration (and therefore need more support).