Banter Rate this song...

Stanthropical

Stanthropical

De̸͍̺̺̓̾m̶̶̶ͫͫod̶̶̶ͩͩu̶̶̶ͧͧLaᴛ̶̶ⷮo̵̢̦̟͋̾̓r
Rate the last posted song (any source) in EACH of the following individual categories:

Instrumentals:
Vocals:
Lyrics:
Recording (sound) Quality:
Overall Performance:

If applicable/optional:

Video Quality:
Video Creativity:
Video Entertainment:

You have three rating systems to choose from and you can mix them if you like, but use only one rating system per category:

Star system: 1 - 5; 1 being POOR and 5 being EXCELLENT

Number system; 1 - 10: 1 being POOR and 10 being EXCELLENT.

Emotional system; 1 - 10: 1 being POOR and 10 being EXCELLENT.
(1)GTFO or Junk,
(2)WTF is this noise? or LMAO,
(3)Lame or I Want My Time Back or Cringe,
(4)Meh or Bleh,
(5)It's Okay or Decent,
(6)Not Bad or Background Music Quality,
(7)Pretty Good or I'd Add It To My Library,
(8)I like it or It's Great
(9)Nice or Billboard Quality
(10)Excellent or I love it!

After rating, post a song for the next person to rate. Add any commentary or critique, if you like.
 
Y'all doing this wrong.

For above song:
Instrumentals: 3
Vocals: 3
Lyrics: 3
Recording (sound) Quality: 6
Overall Performance: 4

Very generic instrumentals, uninspiring.
Vocalist doesn't sound very experienced, with effects making them sound better than they really are.
Lyrics were boring and not really painting an immersive context.
I wouldn't listen to it again.


 
Instrumentals: 10
Vocals: 9
Lyrics: 9
Recording (sound) Quality: 9
Overall Performance: 9

Video Quality: 7
Video Creativity: 8
Video Entertainment: 10

I actually love the song, great song. I like the look of the video. Ozzy sounds good.

 
Last edited:
Instrumentals: excellent
Vocals: Five Stars
Lyrics: I'd add it to my library
Recording (sound) Quality: 10
Overall Performance: 9

Video Quality: 5
Video Creativity: 8
Video Entertainment: 9

Recording seems like it's in studio, because some things don't match up with the live recording and vocals are perfect by Dio. Sound quality is fantastic, considering the year recorded.

The musicians are distinguished professionals and their performances leave no doubt in that. Lyrics are clear and pretty good, nice and lengthy, although a little too vague to interpret what they're about.


 
Instrumentals: 4/5
Vocals: 4/5
Lyrics: 4/5
Recording (sound) Quality: 4/5
Overall Performance: 4/5

Video Quality: 2
Video Creativity: 1
Video Entertainment: 1

Great song with strong instrumentals! The riffs and drums communicate the pissed off tone she’s going for. Lyrics are good and paint the picture of the asshole going after his prey. It’s too bad the didn’t come out with a video with more creativity, could be a fun one! Side note- this was one of the first popular female led groups in rock music, and to come out with a song calling out a man for being a dick in the 70s was pretty powerful!

 
Instrumentals:
Vocals: 4
Lyrics: 2
Recording (sound) Quality: 7
Overall Performance: 5

Video Quality: 3
Video Creativity: 6
Video Entertainment: 3

No, I didn't care for this one. From this, I'm not too excited to hear more of their stuff.

 
Ahh, what a let down lol. There’s so much critiquing that could be done on that song, whether liked or not! :p

Instrumentals: 4/5
Vocals: NA
Lyrics: NA
Recording (sound) Quality: 3/5
Overall Performance: 3/5

Video Quality: NA
Video Creativity: NA
Video Entertainment: NA

Most of these topics aren’t applicable to the song. But, this is a creepy/dark sounding intro to the album which probably sets the mood for the rest of the album. Awesome guitar work that seems to go from chaotic to more structured. I like the combination of orchestral music with rock.

 
Instrumentals: 4/5
Vocals: 4/5
Lyrics: 4/5
Recording (sound) Quality: 4/5
Overall Performance: 4/5

Video Quality: 5/5
Video Creativity: 5/5
Video Entertainment: 5/5

Hawt.


 
Instrumentals: 5
Vocals: 3
Lyrics: 4
Recording (sound) Quality: 5
Overall Performance: 4

Video Quality: 4
Video Creativity: 2
Video Entertainment: 4

Ok, I liked the beginning, with her singing, thought ok this is pretty good but did not like the male angry yelling.
Was hopeful but a little let down, I'm not into that angry metal. Wondering if she sings on her own. I would think so, hoping lol

 
Instrumentals: Excellent
Vocals: Excellent
Lyrics: Excellent
Recording (sound) Quality: Excellent
Overall Performance: Excellent

Video Quality: 9
Video Creativity: 10
Video Entertainment: 9

Every aspect of production is excellent, considering the year. Expert instrumentals. Expert vocals--not many vocalists have such a huge vocal range. The lyrics blow away any dumb ass music of the last several decades.


 
Instrumentals:
Vocals: 3
Lyrics: 5
Recording (sound) Quality 4
Overall Performance: 4

Video Quality: 6
Video Creativity: 2
Video Entertainment: 5

(2) WTF is this noise?

I like her voice, I would like to hear her sing a song where a guy doesn't sing over her all angry, I guess someone who likes metal would probably appreciate all the vocals I guess :eek: but to me, the screaming is just noise.
The band is good. The background music is good

 
Last edited:
Peony0375 said:
Instrumentals:
Vocals: 3
Lyrics: 5
Recording (sound) Quality 4
Overall Performance: 4

Video Quality: 6
Video Creativity: 2
Video Entertainment: 5

I like her voice, I would like to hear her sing a song where a guy doesn't sing over her all angry, I guess someone who likes metal would probably appreciate all the vocals I guess :eek: but to me, the screaming is just noise.
The band is good. The background music is good

Click to expand...
That’s her voice, not a male screaming over her!
 
Instrumentals:1/5
Vocals: 2/5
Lyrics: 3
Recording (sound) Quality 2/5
Overall Performance: 2/5

Video Quality: 2/5
Video Creativity: 1/5
Video Entertainment: 0/5

Painful to watch and listen to. The song doesn’t do a good job of expressing the message of the lyrics.

 
Instrumentals: Not bad
Vocals: Bleh
Lyrics: Bleh
Recording (sound) Quality: Billboard Quality
Overall Performance: Background Music Quality

Video Quality: 3/5
Video Creativity: LMAO
Video Entertainment: JUNK

 
Instrumentals: 5/5
Vocals: NA
Lyrics: NA
Recording (sound) Quality: 5/5
Overall Performance: 5/5

Video Quality: I like it
Video Creativity: I like it
Video Entertainment: Love it

Impressive. They are able to keep it interesting and captivating, which is sometimes difficult with this genre. You can feel their energy watching them, I was entertained.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top