Well this died fast.. lol.
If anyone is still there to answer- Is there a such thing as physically attraction without a mental connection? Why or why not?
I certainly think there is and it is quite common. One can be physically attracted to another without knowing the other person at all. I imagine this is how many (not saying all) one night stands happen.
Personally, I can definitely be physically attracted to someone, but to REALLY be attracted to a person I have to have some sort of mental connection. Don't need their life story or anything, but I have to experience a bond or connection with her. Sharing some common views, having some similar likes, being able to interact with each other, be open with each other (this is build over time, of course), and being playful with each other are things I seek in building a mental connection with someone. Some physical attraction must be there for me in order to form a mental connection... otherwise it just doesn't work for me.
I've said it before, but I can find someone very attractive and absolutely ravishing until she opens her mouth or I see how she acts. If she talks down to people, is demanding, or talks only about herself, then my physical attraction is gone for her. Similarly if she treats people bad, uses people, acts self-centered, is arrogant, or is pushy, then I am like fuck no, I don't want anything to do with her. I can still find her looks appealing, but I won't be attracted to her in any way, shape, or form.
Hope this provides some decent thoughts on your question. : )