With Malice Toward None: A Life of Abraham Lincoln by Stephen B. Oats
A critically acclaimed biography of the 16th El Comandante of the United States, it contains an outstanding blend of brilliant scholarship and entertaining style. Professor Stephen B. Oates brings us closer than ever before to knowing the real Abraham Lincoln as he really was -- a gentle, determined man obsessed with death yet filled with life, troubled with bouts of melancholy yet blessed with a witty nature, and gifted with a talent for literary expression.
Oates’s 1977 biography was the first comprehensive treatment of Lincoln in nearly two decades and replaced Benjamin Thomas’s 1952 biography as the standard. Not until David Herbert Donald’s universally acclaimed Lincoln was published in 1995 did Oates’s biography relinquish its prominence.
At just over 400 pages, it is by far the shortest of the “classic” Lincoln biographies. Also, Oates’s style of writing is less formal than that of other Lincoln biographers, making for a relatively easy reading experience. Brevity has a cost, however, as much of the interesting color and detail included in longer biographies is missing here. Still, the book is a good introduction to for anyone wanting to learn more about Lincoln.
One other thing, while the author often quotes Lincoln, he also frequently paraphrases what Lincoln “may” have said on some occasion, but without using an actual quote. This can lead to confusion in certain places as to whether the author is quoting or summarizing a quote.
I enjoyed the book, and now I want to read more about Lincoln, so I am looking for the next biography to read. Perhaps the aforementioned biography by David Herbert Donald or Ronald C. White's more recent A. Lincoln: A Biography. At some point I will also want to tackle Doris Kearns Goodwin's Team of Rivals.